How the Comparisons were Made
An analytical model has been
constructed based on the individual recommendations of seven published
nutritional authorities. Each authority is recongized and
respeted
within the scientific, medical or naturopathic communities.
Each has
also published one or more works, citing specific recommendations for
daily nutritional intakes. They are Phyllis Balch, CNC, Dr
Michael
Colgan, PhD., Dr. Earl Mindell, PhD., Dr. Michael Nurray, ND., Dr.
Richard Passwater, Ph.D., Dr. Ray Strand, M.D., and Dr Julian Whitaker,
MD.
The
Blended Nutritional Standard
To construct the
analytical model, the individual recommendations for daily nutritional
intake from the seven cited nutritional authorities were assessed and
pooled. While each author's recommedations had a few
characteristics
not recongized by the others, there was substantial commonality.
A
Blended Nutritional Standard was created as those areas of commonality
were exploited.
Qualifying the
Products and the Final Product Score
The
Upper Limit of daily intake (UL) is a component of the new Dictary
Reference Intake (DRI) standards currenly under joint development by
the United States and Canada. The UL represets the upper
level of
intake for a specific nutrient deemed to be safe for use by adults.
Qualifying
products are assessed quantitatively to provide a percentage ranking
relative to the Blended
Standard. Fourteen criteria are employed in
determing relative product standings.
- Completeness
- Does the product contain the full spectrum of nutrients listed in the
Blended Standard and considered essetial for optimal health?
- Potency
- Of those nutrients in the product, what percent are found at potency
levels meeting or exceeding 50 percent of the potency for those
nutrients in the Blended Standard?
- Bioavailability
-Does the product contain minerals in their most bioavailable forms as
amino acid chelates or organic acid complexes?
- Bioactivity
of Vitamin E
- Does the product contain only the d-isomer of vitaminE (the natural,
biologically active form of alpha tocopherol) or does the product use
the d/l isomers of isomers of vitamin E ( asynthetic form, where the
biological activity is about one-half (or less) of the natural vitamin
E)?
- Cardiac
Health Triad
- Does the product contain vitamin E, coenzyme Q10 and magnesium, three
nutritional components important to cardic health, at potencies that
meet or exeed 50 percent of the Blended Standard?
- Homocysteine
Reduction Triad
- Does the product contain the nutritional triad of vitamin B6, vitamin
B12 and folic acid, at levels meeting or exceeding 50 percent of the
Blended Standard?
- Bone
Health Complex -
Does the product contain the nutrients shown by clinical studies to be
important for optimal bone health (viamin D, vitamin K, folic acid,
vitamin B6, vitamin B12, boron, aclcium, magnesium, silicon and zinc)
at potencies equal to or exceeding 50 percent of the potencies listed
in the Blended Standard?
- Antioxidant
Triad
- Does the product contain the important antioxidant triad of vitamin
E, vitamin C and beta-carotene at potencies equal to or exceeding 50
percent of the potencies listed in the Blended Standard?
- Glutathione
Support-
Does the porduct contain the nutritional precursors necessary for
glutathione synthesis and the proper functioning of the Glutathione
Peroxidase Pathway, at potencies equal to or exceeding 50 percent of
the potencies listed in the Blended Standard?
- Metabolic
Support
- Does the product contain teh nutrients neccesssary to help regulate
glucose metabolism and support teh body's ability to generate, store
and utilize energy, and are these nutrients avaible at potencies equal
to or exceeding 50 percent of the potencies listed in the Blended
Starndard?
- Bioflavonoid
Profile
- Does the product contain a mixture of bioflavonoids (citrus
flavonoids, soy isofalvones, quercetin, quercitrin, hesperidin, rutin,
bilberry extract and green tea catechins, and proanthocyanidins at
potencies that meet or exceed 50 percent of the combined recommended
potencies for PCOs and mixed bioflavonoids in the Blended Standard?
- Phenolic
Compond Profile
- Does the product contain phenolic compounds (polyphenolic acids and
their derivatives, including surcumin) at a potency level recently
established in the literature (25mg) that have been associated with a
reduced incidence of coronary heart disease?
- Lipotropic
Factors
- Does the product contain the important lipotropic factors, choline
(including phosphatidylcholine) and inositol, at levels meeting or
exeeding 50 percent of the Blended Standard?
- Potential
Toxicities - Does the nutritional supplement contain of
vitamin A and iron that exeed 100% of the Blended Standard?
From
these fourteen criteria, a Final Product Score, based on a percentage
ranking, is calculated. A score approachng 100% represents a
product taht possesses those characteristics for optimal nutrition, as
reflected in
the Blended Standard; conversely, a low percent score
represtes a product possessing few, if any, of the characteristics fro
optimal nutritin, as reflected in the Blended Standard. |